WHAT YOU NEED
TO KNOW ABOUT BUILDING A NEW HOME!
Deciding to build a new
home is one of the biggest decisions most people make in their
lifetimes and is also a large investment. The next important
decision is choosing a builder. Unlike many other items that
you have purchased or will purchase in the future, your choice
in a builder will directly affect the quality and value of your
new home forever. Consider this: no two builders will construct
your home the same way. Your new home has well over 1000 different
items being installed, from the footings to the finishing touches.
Also, over 100 people will usually be involved with the building
of your home. Ultimately, choosing a builder is the most important
decision you can make and is one that should not be made lightly.
Here are several things to consider and some suggestions that
will make the experience of building a new home pleasurable
and rewarding.
The First Step -
Design
The first step is to determine
your needs and wants. Hiring a professional engineer or architect
is a good idea, but can be expensive. Average residential design
services can range from $500 to several thousand dollars depending
on the scope and details of the project. However, this investment
will likely pay off in a better designed home that meets your
needs of today and tomorrow. Experienced professionals will
help you understand your needs and wants, options and how they
impact the cost of building, maintenance and potential resale
value. Professionals take into account local building codes,
weather in the area, and much more. Many times, they can incorporate
your ideas and dreams in an efficient manner as compared to
a mass produced design from a book.
Many people also purchase
plans from the internet or books. Remember, while these prints
are able to built from they may require alteration for the area
and local building codes prior to use. Also, these are not personalized
and do not involve the experience and benefit of one-on-one
consultation, which makes a huge difference in the end result.
Prints and designs purchased from production sites are often
not designed for efficiency, both in building and living costs.
Some companies are design-build,
which means they offer the design services in-house (with their
own staff) as well as building services. This can lead to a
very well planned and cost efficient project. Also, with this
type of company, design changes can be made more easily during
construction because the design professional is on staff and
involved with the project. Outside professionals usually charge
additional fees for any modifications, unforeseen problems,
or site visits. Finally, some design-build companies will reduce
or waive design fees if you are utilizing their building services
as well.
Bidding and Contracting
Now that you have a design,
you must get a price, choose a builder, and contract. First,
you should be familiar with three types of construction documents.
1. Prints or drawings are commonly called blueprints. Prints
show a graphical representation of the home and are used by
the builder as a set of instructions on how to build the home.
Prints show things such as quantity and location of items, dimensions
and construction details. 2. Specifications (Specs. for short)
are documents that describe the quality of items being used
in building your new home. 3. The Written Contract describes
how the process will take place and the relationship between
you (the owner) and the Builder. Contracts should contain, at
minimum, clauses that address construction start and completion
dates, price, scope of work, payment, allowances, unforeseen
circumstances, and changes to the scope of work and dispute
resolution. The prints and specifications are considered part
of the contract as well. It is important that these documents
be complete and that you review them thoroughly to avoid misunderstandings.
Now you are ready to move
on to the bidding process. Some people will collect multiple
bids for their new home. This is not necessarily done to get
the best price, but rather to determine if a price is reasonable.
Bids for the same house, with the same specifications may vary
by as much as 5%-10%, usually, the larger the project, the less
variation, unless the detail level is great or complex.
Why Do Bids Vary?
Well, since no two contractors
will build your house the same way, it seems logical that no
two bids would be the same. The most common reasons for variations
include materials, labor and company structure. Let’s
start with materials. Project specifications should spell out
the quality of the materials to be used. Be weary of project
specs that consist of only a list of 10 items that you easily
identify with easily such as windows and trim. Vague specifications
leave much to be decided by the builder, which may not be in
your best interest. Remember there are over 1000 items going
into your new home, and your investment. For example, what is
the concrete strength specified at? This material holds up your
entire house and it is vital that it be defined in the specifications.
Higher quality concrete will cost more and is necessary for
a long-lasting foundation. Also, how will the builder verify
that the concrete meets strength? Will they test it? These types
of procedures would be part of a Quality Assurance Program.
All-to-often, people planning to have a home built only look
at the finish items and forget about the important structural
items that make up 50% of the material costs. You should review
specifications carefully to make sure that the majority of the
materials are defined either by type, brand or industry standard
such as ASTM (American Society of Testing and Materials). When
comparing bids, ensure that the specs are the same. Otherwise,
you are not comparing apples to apples.
Bids will also vary due
to labor costs and company structure. Labor type and costs varies
from company to company. How the work will be done and who will
perform the work is critical, since everything must be installed
on site. Specifications typically do not address labor since
finished results are subjective in nature and techniques to
accomplish this may vary. Here are the most common company structures.
Construction Management
Companies (CMs)
This term is often mistakenly
interchanged with general contractors. A Construction Management
company has no field employees (people who perform the actual
building of your home). You are paying for their experience
and management abilities. These types of companies could be
made up of one person or a group of people whom act as managers.
CMs hire or sublet all phases of the construction out to other
companies, typically called subcontractors. A subcontractor
usually specializes in one type of work, such as masonry or
plumbing and may work for many builders in the same area. However,
this also means that the company that performed the work on
the model you visited may not be the same company that performs
the work on your house. CMs do not have control over who their
subcontractors hire or assign to perform the work on your house.
In fact, while the hiring of subcontractors is quite common,
it limits the control of the builder both over schedule and
quality of work performed. CMs may also have difficulty in resolving
disputes and warranty issues, but we will discuss this more
in another section. These companies usually have high overhead
and labor costs.
Sole Proprietorship
This type of company usually
consists of one or two people whom perform most of if not all
the work. This was more common many years ago, but still exists
today in some areas. While there are advantages to really knowing
who is performing the work and having a relationship with them
directly, this operation comes with great risk. What happens
if they become ill or incapacitated? While this is not a pleasant
thought, the reality is that all of your eggs are in one basket.
Another concern is that a sole proprietorship business commingles
company and personal business. This means what happens to that
builder personally effects their business and vise-versa. This
does not mean that they this type of builder is incapable, just
that there is greater risk. These companies usually have low
overhead and labor costs.
General Contractors
The best scenario is a hybrid
of the two, a company that hires subcontractors and directly
employs craftsmen. This type of company is known as a General
Contractor. They typically subcontract out specialized work
such as excavation and utilities, while using their own employees
to perform many other tasks. This reduces the risk while optimizing
schedule, performance and control over quality. This type of
structure also protects owners if something should happen to
one employee or subcontractor. Typically these companies have
moderate overhead and labor costs. Many design-build companies
fall under this category. It is suggested that you inquire as
to what type of structure a company has when choosing a builder.
Evaluating Bids
Here are some important
things to keep in mind when comparing bids. On the surface,
many builders claim to build the same house and most people
get caught up in the price. It’s usually not the high
bid you have to worry about, it’s the low bid. Be especially
concerned about bids that are more than 10% less than the average.
Most of the time this suggests something was omitted. Even if
everything is well spelled out in drawings and specifications,
doesn’t mean that a builder didn’t make a mistake;
and you don’t want builders omitting items or “losing
money”! Builders most commonly omit items when they use
“square foot” bidding techniques, but this will
be described in more detail later. First, let’s look at
the “losing money” statement. It sounds strange
to say, but consider this; a builder that is losing money or
discovers an omission after a projected is contracted is in
a tight spot. This situation does not give that builder an incentive
to build your project to the best of their ability; actually
they now have incentive to cut corners, increase change order
costs to make up costs associated with the mistake.
Something else to seriously
consider is even though you are smart, your builder is smarter.
This is their profession and it is not realistic to think that
you can be there all the time to watch over things. Many items
go unnoticed or are hidden in the foundation, walls, roof and
other systems or your home. It is good for your builder to make
a reasonable profit. Let’s face it; you want this guy
around in the future in case there is a problem or warranty
issue. If your builder goes out-of-business, you are out of
luck. Therefore, be concerned about why a bid is lower than
the average. This is not to say that the low bidder is always
made a mistake, just a cautionary note to be weary of bids that
are drastically less than the average.
Something else to consider
about mistakes that have resulted in “too good to be true”
low bids is that a large mistake may force the builder out-of
business. That means they won’t be there for service after
the sale. Worse yet, this could happen while they are in the
middle of building your house. This can result in long delays,
liens on your project and worst of all, increased costs to complete
the project. In fact, it will likely cost you double to get
another contractor involved with a project that has already
begun. This is due to concerns with liability for work they
have not performed, uncertainty about what was done right or
wrong, etc. For example, once the drywall is up, it’s
difficult to tell if the wiring, plumbing, insulation, etc.
was installed correctly. Many contractors, builders, and subcontractors
will not even consider picking up after a bankrupt builder at
any price. So the moral of the story is, while you want a fair
price, you want a builder to bid the job correctly and make
a fair profit in building you a great home. Typically if the
bids are within 5-10% of the average, you have a fair price
and your decision should be made on other items we have discussed.
Bidding Methods
There are a few ways to
price a project, square foot (a form of unit pricing), lump
sum (fixed) and cost plus. Let’s look at these individually:
Square Foot Pricing
This one of the most common
methods used in residential building. This can translate into
a fixed or lump sum contract, but be weary of this method of
calculation. Not all the square foot of your house costs the
same. For example, a kitchen is more expensive than a bedroom;
a two-story great room is more expensive than a single-story
great room, etc. Also the term square footage should be defined.
Typically, square footage refers to the living space of your
home, which does include finished, heated space such as sunrooms
and bonus rooms. However, garages are usually not included,
but there is a difference between the cost of a two-car and
three-car garage. There are also other costs that are not affected
by square footage, such as utilities, driveways and sewers.
Ultimately, square foot pricing is good to determine an approximate
price of construction, not to contract too. If the calculated
value, by square foot, is within 10-15% of your budget, it suggests
that the size and style of home is most likely obtainable. If
not, you may wish to consider a different size, design or style.
Lump Sum Contracts
and Take-Off Bids
After the design is completed,
a builder should perform an actual take-off bid. Essentially,
the builder builds your house in their mind and on paper, most
likely with a computer. This process makes a builder familiar
with your project identifying special construction concerns,
details and many items that would go unnoticed in a square foot
bid. If not done this way, it often results in omissions as
mentioned earlier. Take off bids are the fairest method of bidding
to both the owner and builder. However, they require more time
to perform.
After a thorough take-off
has been completed, a builder can complete a lump sum bid. This
gives you piece of mind, knowing that the builder has committed
to building your house at a certain price, but remember, time
is of the essence. In today’s market materials and even
labor fluctuates regularly. Prices can only be “locked
in” for so long, so move quickly. Again, if uncertainty
can be minimized, such as the cost of materials, it will help
a builder reduce the price. It is common for builders to only
hold a price for 30 days.
Cost Plus
This type of bid/contract
is used often when construction must begin before the design
is completed or when something must be built quickly. Usually
the builder provides the owner with a rough estimate of the
total cost. However, cost plus contracts are set up for the
Owner to pay actual costs for materials and labor (in-house
labor is typically set up at an hourly rate) and then a percentage
over that. Because of the reduced uncertainty for the builder,
the percent profit should be on the lower end of the range mentioned
above. This can be done very effectively in residential construction
however; it reduces the risk for the builder and places more
of the risk upon the owner since you have no commitment on price.
The builder invoices for materials and labor performed using
a summary of actually costs so that you know what the actual
costs are. This can result in a lower cost for the owner if
managed properly. Also, if you expect a lot of changes, it may
be more effective to go with a cost plus bid.
All of these methods have
an appropriate application. It is recommended to use square
foot bidding to get an idea for the house design as compared
to your budget. Then get a fixed or cost plus bid/contract based
on your needs and situation.
A final note on bids, a
common profit in the home building industry is between 8-15%.
Usually, the builders at the higher end are more experienced
or reputable. Sometimes a high bid can be made in error or be
a sign that a builder has too much work at that particular time.
This way if the builder gets the bid, he can pay the overtime
necessary to perform the work. If something seems too good to
be true, it most likely is. For your new home, which is a major
investment, maybe your dream home now is not the time to cut
corners. Perform the proper research and make the investment
of time in selecting a builder. Your decision here, will affect
you for the rest of your life.
Other important traits to
consider in choosing a builder are professionalism and follow-up.
Don’t be too concerned that something may go wrong during
the building of your new home, because it most likely will.
Be interested in how a company handles mistakes and handles
situations after the job is completed. This is a far better
attribute than just working through the construction period.
After all, your home will be around a lot longer than six months.
The best suggestion is to
go with a builder that you feel comfortable with, have a relationship
with, good references for and that scores well on the checklists
provided. If their bid is not the lowest, approach them with
this. Many times a difference in specifications may be determined
or adjustments made. Some builders will reduce costs, for reducing
risk on a project such as varying material costs, definite start
dates for scheduling, known soil and site conditions, controlled
allowances, etc.
For more information on the building process or a free consultation,
please contact us at 440-997-4238 or send us an email at qconstruct@alltel.net.
We look forward to working with you!
Click
here to view and utilize a checklist we've made for you when
evaluating home builders.